January 10, 2011

Is Something Wrong With Scientific Method?

Jonah Lehrer, New Yorker


New Yorker

On September 18, 2007, a few dozen neuroscientists, psychiatrists, and drug-company executives gathered in a hotel conference room in Brussels to hear some startling news. It had to do with a class of drugs known as atypical or second-generation antipsychotics, which came on the market in the early nineties. The drugs, sold under brand names such as Abilify, Seroquel, and Zyprexa, had been tested on schizophrenics in several large clinical trials, all of which had demonstrated a dramatic decrease in the subjects’ psychiatric symptoms. As a result, second-generation antipsychotics had become one of the fastest-growing and most profitable pharmaceutical classes. By 2001, Eli Lilly’s Zyprexa was generating more revenue than Prozac. It remains the company’s ...

Read Full Article ››

TAGGED: decline effect, statistical significance, publication bias, scientific research, scientific journals, scientific method

RECOMMENDED ARTICLES

May 9, 2012
Why Science Can't Make Cookies Like Mama Did
Irwin Gelman, Scientist
All of us know the apocryphal tale where the mother-in-law “shares” a secret family recipe, but as much as you try, the cookies never taste the same as Mama’s.  Of course, Mama’s withholding of the... more ››
May 14, 2012
Can We Test Politicians' Ideas with Science?
Mark Henderson, Guardian
"All life is an experiment," wrote Ralph Waldo Emerson. "The more experiments you make the better." It's a maxim that is the stuff of science, the foundation stone of an approach to discovery that delivers reliable, if... more ››
May 7, 2012
Can Science Be Applied to Business, Policy?
Trevor Butterworth, WSJ
Imagine that you are the chief executive for a chain of 10,000 convenience stores, 8,000 of them called QwikMart, 2,000 of them called FastMart. Strangely, the FastMarts are bringing in 10% more in sales on average than the... more ››
May 10, 2012
Open Access Might Hurt Poor Researchers
Bynner & Goldstein, Guardian
The present academic publishing system obstructs the free communication of research findings. By erecting paywalls, commercial publishers prevent scientists from downloading research papers unless they pay substantial fees.... more ››
May 5, 2012
Read Science Press Releases or the Papers?
Hank Campbell, Science 2.0
We carry some press releases on Science 2.0 and of course that is what Science Codex in our sidebar is. It's been an intentional effort since the communications arm of Science 2.0 began in 2006. The first, and most important... more ››